RFPs in a Connection Economy, or “Death by RFP”

I woke up today gearing up to write a proposal for a $25,000 project. It’s one of those tasks that won’t take very long once I get going, but not necessarily my favorite way to spend a beautiful day.Drinking a cup of coffee and pouring through the news on LinkedIn, I came across an Inc article titled “Death by RFP: 7 Reasons Not to Respond” by John Warrillow.

Great way to get motivated to write that proposal.

It made sense to me. To sum up Warrillow’s 7 reasons why RFPs are bad for your business:

  1. Tendered business doesn’t stick: RFPs don’t lead to repeat business
  2. RFPs dilute your differentiation: you get shoved in a box with “half-rate competitors who compete on price.” Ouch.
  3. RFPs cut your margins: it’s all about how cheaply you can deliver on the specifications
  4. They decide the rules, not you: you let the customer tell you how to do your job
  5. They’re rigged: usually the decision has been made before the RFP is released
  6. They send the wrong message to your people: your employees scramble around writing up a response, pricing out a budget, and if you’re really unlucky giving away your IP. They’ll wonder why.
  7. RFPs undermine your company’s sellability: companies with a unique service or product are more likely to get repeat business than those selling a commodity.

Seth Godin talks at length about what he calls the connection economy in his most recent book, “Icarus Deception: How High will you Fly?” (2012). One of its core repeating messages is the importance of authentic relationships in business and life in today’s economy.

How much easier – and fun – is it to spend your business development time developing relationships with interesting people at companies that resonate with your purpose and values? I’d much rather have a client and a project emerge from a deep connection I’ve fostered than from a proposal I wrote to strangers not knowing much about their endeavor, the project, or what they are looking for.

What do you think about RFPs? What’s your favorite way to seal a deal? How much does the connection economy figure into your business strategy?

(Blog originally published at Lupine Collaborative on March 6 2013)

1 COMMENT

  1. You raise excellent points, Deb. I used to write responses to government RFPs for a private sector company. In many cases, reputation and reliability (part of which are built through professional relationships) were as much criteria in the final decision as was cost. 

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.